DC Rudge wants to search the home of Dawes, who has agreed to allow officers to search for evidence of a fraud. Dawes has not been arrested and is under no legal obligation to allow the search. DC Rudge asks about the requirements under Code B before conducting the search. Which of the following most accurately states the legal position under Code B para 5?
- ADC Rudge may proceed with the search immediately - where the occupier consents, no further formalities are required before the search can begin.
- BDC Rudge must first obtain a search warrant even where the occupier consents - consent is not a valid basis for a search under Code B.
- CDC Rudge must caution Dawes and inform him that anything found may be used in evidence - failure to caution before a consent search renders any evidence inadmissible.
- DBefore searching with consent, DC Rudge must make reasonable enquiries to ensure Dawes is entitled to grant consent, tell Dawes he is not obliged to consent, and obtain and make a written record of his consent.
Show answer and explanation
Code B para 5 sets out the requirements for searches with consent. Before conducting a consent search, the officer must: (1) make reasonable enquiries to be satisfied the person consenting is entitled to grant entry to the premises; (2) tell the person they are not obliged to consent and the search can only go ahead if they do; and (3) obtain and make a written record of the consent. These steps ensure consent is genuine, informed, and properly documented. A caution is not required before a consent search.
- A: Where the occupier consents, a warrant is not required - but the Code B para 5 formalities must still be followed before the search begins. The officer cannot simply proceed without fulfilling the consent search requirements.
- B: Consent is a valid basis for a search under Code B. A warrant is not required where genuine informed consent is given. Code B para 5 specifically governs consent searches.
- C: A caution is not required before a consent search under Code B. The caution requirement arises when a person is to be interviewed under suspicion - it has no application to the execution of a consent search.