Sgt Clement is reviewing a complaint against PC Pocock. PC Pocock used force during an arrest and the suspect, Noble, was taken to hospital with a broken arm. The force was disputed. Sgt Clement asks DC Rosario whether the matter must be referred to the IOPC. Which of the following most accurately states the legal position?
- AAny use of force resulting in injury to a member of the public is a mandatory referral to the IOPC.
- BThe matter is a discretionary referral - the chief constable may refer it to the IOPC but is not required to do so unless the injury is life-threatening.
- CThe matter must be referred to the IOPC because a broken arm constitutes serious injury within the meaning of the Police Reform Act 2002 - death or serious injury following contact with police is a mandatory referral and the force has no discretion to handle it locally.
- DThe matter must be referred to the professional standards department within 24 hours but does not need to be referred to the IOPC unless the investigation reveals gross misconduct.
Show answer and explanation
Under Schedule 3 to the Police Reform Act 2002 and the IOPC Statutory Guidance, certain matters are mandatory referrals to the IOPC. These include cases where death or serious injury (DSI) has resulted from contact with the police. A broken arm resulting from force used during an arrest falls within the definition of serious injury under the regulations. The force has no discretion to handle DSI cases locally - referral is mandatory and must be made as soon as practicable. Whether PC Pocock acted lawfully is irrelevant - the trigger is the outcome.
- A: Not any injury triggers a mandatory referral. The threshold is serious injury - minor injuries do not require IOPC referral. A broken arm, however, does constitute serious injury within the mandatory referral criteria.
- B: DSI cases are not discretionary referrals. The chief constable has no discretion to handle DSI matters locally - mandatory referral is required as soon as practicable.
- D: The mandatory referral to the IOPC does not await the outcome of an internal investigation. It must be made as soon as practicable following the serious injury - not after a gross misconduct finding.