Over four months, Trevor repeatedly drives past the home of his former colleague, Amanda, waits outside her workplace and sends her emails asking to meet. Amanda has made clear she does not want contact. Trevor has never made any direct threat. DC Henshaw considers whether an offence of stalking under s.2A Protection from Harassment Act 1997 is made out. Which of the following is correct?
- ANo offence of stalking is made out as Trevor has made no threats - s.2A requires the course of conduct to include at least one threatening act or communication.
- BAn offence of stalking may be made out - s.2A applies where a course of conduct amounts to harassment and the acts involved are associated with stalking, including monitoring a person, loitering near their home or workplace and contacting them.
- CNo offence of stalking is made out as the course of conduct must cause the victim to fear violence - without fear of violence s.2A cannot be established.
- DAn offence may be made out but only under s.4A PHA 1997 - s.2A stalking only applies where the conduct has caused serious alarm or distress affecting daily activities.
Show answer and explanation
s.2A PHA 1997 creates an offence of stalking where a person pursues a course of conduct that amounts to harassment and the acts or omissions involved are ones associated with stalking. s.2A(3) provides a non-exhaustive list including following a person, contacting or attempting to contact a person by any means, and loitering in any place. No direct threats are required. Fear of violence is not a requirement of s.2A - that is the threshold for the aggravated offence under s.4A.
- A: s.2A does not require any threatening act or communication. The offence is constituted by a course of conduct amounting to harassment that involves acts associated with stalking - threats are not a necessary element.
- C: Fear of violence is the threshold for the aggravated stalking offence under s.4A PHA 1997, not for the s.2A offence. s.2A can be made out without any fear of violence.
- D: This confuses s.2A and s.4A. s.2A is the basic stalking offence and does not require serious alarm or distress affecting daily activities - that is the additional element required under s.4A(1)(b).